A key motivator for this trip was my desire to see some of the battlefields of the Great War, partly because of an interest in history, and partly because my grandfather fought in France and Belgium.
After doing some online research I settled on two tours run by Over the Top Tours, a company based in Ieper, Belgium. Dad and I flew to Brussels from London, and then caught the train to Ieper. The following day we did the tours run by Over the Top and found them to be very interesting and worthwhile.
The morning itinerary included Essex Farm Cemetery, made famous by its links to John McCrae’s poem In Flanders Fields; Tyne Cot Cemetery; a German cemetery called Langemarck; the site of the first poison gas attack; Polygon Wood (which is now a beautiful and peaceful spot); and the Passchendaele museum which includes a recreation of a dug out, an underground military post. Our tour guide Andre was very informative and as only Australians were on the tour, he focused on information about our nation’s involvement in the conflict.
While very interesting, the morning tour was also rather overwhelming emotionally. We heard about so many dead, so many missing, and often for no appreciable gain. Sometimes all that divided the Allied and German forces was the width of a road, and often ground gained one day at great loss of life would be lost a week or a month later. We heard about the horrors of gas warfare, utilised by both sides, and saw a stockpile of old munitions – small hand thrown bombs (the term “grenade” was not then in use), rifles, shells and so on – dug up since the war. Andre said farmers are accustomed to placing any large items on the roadside so they can be collected by the authorities. Last year, almost 100 years since the war started, 170 tonnes of old explosives were collected and disposed of.
Fortunately the afternoon tour, which included four Australians and four Americans, focused more on strategy and less on loss of life. We visited Hill 60, where Australian miners successfully tunnelled under German forces and set 21 huge explosive deposits. When these were detonated the explosion killed 10 000 Germans (the figures of the dead are inescapable) and was instrumental in the Allies winning at Messines. Hill 60 and the craters the explosions created are still there: some look like the natural contours of the land now, but others, like the Caterpillar Crater and the 70 foot deep Pool of Peace, are recognizable as bomb sites. There are also some German bunkers still in place at Hill 60, though you can’t go in them. A movie was made about the Australian miners a few years ago, but I haven’t seen it.
Trench warfare was experienced for the first time in World War I, and it was an horrendous experience for the men involved. Aside from the obvious danger of being killed, they had to deal with mud which could be knee or waist height, trench foot, lice, fleas and rats, among other things.
We visited a recreation of a German trench at Westhork, built on the site of an original trench line discovered after the war. Andre explained that the Germans used an inverted A frame design, with the peak of the A on the ground and wooden planks on the cross bar to allow water to flow underneath, with walls reinforced by strips of wood wound together. This meant they were drier and more stable than the Allied trenches, which flooded more easily. Over 63,000 miles of trenches were dug during the war.
The trenches and bunkers highlighted an interesting difference between the Allied and German approach to the conflict: as Andre put it, the Germans focused on creating areas they could defend, such as sturdy trenches and bunkers, whereas the Allied commanders saw their forces as always moving forwards, and therefore saw no reason to create fortified positions that could be defended. This meant that when the battle lines didn’t change much, the Allied troops were often in less comfortable and less secure conditions than their enemies.
In addition, the Germans had been planning their attack on France for years, and thus were better prepared and, initially at least, better equipped than the Allies. For example, they had many lethal machine guns with a killing range of 1.5 miles. The Allied commanders had seen machine guns demonstrated but decided they were not a weapon which would be of value.
Similarly, he said the Allies fought the war the way they’d fought all previous ones: blast the enemy lines with artillery, then send in the infantry. This meant the enemy knew what to expect, at least until some different tactics were employed, like the tunnelling at Hill 60 and to a much lesser extent, at the Somme.
Both Dad and I were left wondering how the Allies managed to win the war, and Andre pointed out that the November 1919 Armistice ended the fighting but not the war – that only ended with the signing of the Treaty of Versailles. The impression I was left with was that the war had reached a stalemate, and Germany only signed the Treaty because it was unable to break the standoff. Also, had the conflict continued there would have been fighting on German territory, something which hadn’t happened up to that point and which the commanders wanted to avoid. But my belief that we “won” the Great War isn’t actually based in fact.
By the end of the afternoon several of us were saying that the whole war had been a colossal waste of life, but Andre offered a different perspective. In his view, the war was necessary to curb German military ambition, but more men died than should have because of the flawed tactics used by some of those in command. Apparently more soldiers died in the Great War than in World War Two, and he attributes that to better strategies being adopted in the latter conflict. Regardless of the reason, having learned more of the destruction of so many lives and homes in the Great War in one part of one country, I am amazed and saddened that 20 years later it all happened again.
-
-
Advanced dressing station
-
-
Tyne Cot Cemetery
-
-
Dad and I at Tyne Cot
-
-
Polygon Wood memorial
-
-
Recovered munitions
-
-
German bunker at Hill 60
-
-
Caterpillar crater at Hill 60
-
-
The Pool of Peace bomb crater
-
-
Dad at the recreated German trenches